BS Scale and DQ of the month

troutheart · Post by **troutheart** » Mon Mar 29, 2010 8:26 pm

I don't know if these would be possible because some angler's can be very sensitive about their fishing but I think it would be hillarious to have some kind of BS scale to rate posts because some of these guys tell "fish stories" and then back them up with pics that prove that they are full of it. I wouldn't mind if someone called BS on me. Also another one that might offend the sensitive type, how about a monthly voting contest for a "washington lakes drama queen or king" with some kind of small prize? Sometimes I feel like i'm on myspace or facebook with the drama some of these fishermen cause. I view this website several times a day to read fishing reports and chat with other people that have the same passion as I. And maybe this "prize" will slow the childesh behavior that some of the members display, maybe not but it will be funny anyway. Rather than drama queen we could call them the "clown fish" or something stupid like that?

Blackmouth · Post by **Blackmouth** » Mon Mar 29, 2010 8:48 pm

troutheart wrote:I don't know if these would be possible because some angler's can be very sensitive about their fishing but I think it would be hillarious to have some kind of BS scale to rat a "washington lakes drama queen or king" with some kind of small prize? Sometimes I feel like i'm on myspace or facebook with thee posts because some of these guys tell "fish stories" and then back them up with pics that prove that they are full of it. I wouldn't mind if someone called BS on me. Also another one that might offend the sensitive type, how about a monthly voting contest for drama some of these fishermen cause. I view this website several times a day to read fishing reports and chat with other people that have the same passion as I. And maybe this "prize" will slow the childesh behavior that some of the members display, maybe not but it will be funny anyway. Rather than drama queen we could call them the "clown fish" or something stupid like that?

For someone who criticizes such behavior, I find your attempt to stir the pot to be quite odd...

I've never understood people who take the internet too seriously. What does it matter to you if some guy posts a 6lber thats really a 4lber? Doesn't matter to me, nor do I feel a need to call him out for it or have something like you propose.

Relax bro, take things a little lighter. It's the internet............

spindog · Post by **spindog** » Mon Mar 29, 2010 10:59 pm

troutheart wrote:I don't know if these would be possible because some angler's can be very sensitive about their fishing but I think it would be hillarious to have some kind of BS scale to rate posts because some of these guys tell "fish stories" and then back them up with pics that prove that they are full of it. I wouldn't mind if someone called BS on me. Also another one that might offend the sensitive type, how about a monthly voting contest for a "washington lakes drama queen or king" with some kind of small prize? Sometimes I feel like i'm on myspace or facebook with the drama some of these fishermen cause. I view this website several times a day to read fishing reports and chat with other people that have the same passion as I. And maybe this "prize" will slow the childesh behavior that some of the members display, maybe not but it will be funny anyway. Rather than drama queen we could call them the "clown fish" or something stupid like that?

Your idea would offend alot of folks and make some quite angry. This site prides itself on not calling people out and not
harassing people, so how do you think this would even be OK? This has the makings for humiliation, harassment, and intimidation.

Post by **Amx** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 6:07 am

As far as pictures go, the camera angle, depth of field setting on the camera, even the amount of sun light between the times of when the pictures were taken, can drasticly change the appearance of the fish in the picture. Not to mention the size of the person's hand/thumb holding the fish. A year and a half ago I caught 2 largemouth a day or 2 days apart. They looked compleatly different but weight exactly the same on my scale. After I got home after the 2nd fish I had to test my scale to see if it was stuck. Both fish weighed 5.7 lbs.

Post by **Mike Carey** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 7:02 am

Always appreciate suggestions for improving the site, but ya, I think this could only lead to some hurt feelings. There are other websites that absolutely are OK with anything goes, but we're just setting the bar a little different here. I think we all develope our own "internal BS meter" over the years. I see lots of 10 pound salmon that in my eyes are 6 pounds. Just the nature of fishing I guess.

troutheart · Post by **troutheart** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 7:03 am

Well I guess there are alot more sensitive people than I thought. Not stirring the pot just having fun

Post by **Toni** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 7:06 am

troutheart wrote:Well I guess there are alot more sensitive people than I thought. Not stirring the pot just having fun

Not my idea of fun.

Post by **Mike Carey** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 7:23 am

troutheart wrote:Well I guess there are alot more sensitive people than I thought. Not stirring the pot just having fun

it's called the silent majority, LOL. no problem.

Rich McVey · Post by **Rich McVey** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 7:29 am

Agreed, For the most part people here are trying to have a conversation and discuss ideas. No need to push people away by having their conversations graded.

If I wanna talk to Toni about downriggers or BS with AMX about props, I dont need my conversation critiqued by a third party.

troutheart · Post by **troutheart** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 8:15 am

you guys all make good points, forget my idea it was a failure. I enjoy exchanging ideas and bsing without offending anyone.

Website · Post by **The Quadfather** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 8:20 am

Everybody come to the center of the circle and group hug your monitor.:farao:

Post by **Mike Carey** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 8:35 am

oh boy, drowning in syrup now. It's feast or famine.

Rich McVey · Post by **Rich McVey** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 9:15 am

Mike Carey wrote:oh boy, drowning in syrup now. It's feast or famine.

'OL GREY DOG · Post by **'OL GREY DOG** » Wed Mar 31, 2010 5:40 am

YEA ok gawd dang it.......just hug'd my monitor......got dust all over me 'n im sneeze'n

kevinb · Post by **kevinb** » Wed Mar 31, 2010 6:44 pm

I can certainly appreciate the humor but it could easily get out of hand.
Their should be an award for the folks that create a 3rd person character and then continue to talk to themselves.
That is beyond weird and creepy but can be semi entertaining.

Post by **Mike Carey** » Wed Mar 31, 2010 9:12 pm

kevinb wrote:I can certainly appreciate the humor but it could easily get out of hand.
Their should be an award for the folks that create a 3rd person character and then continue to talk to themselves.
That is beyond weird and creepy but can be semi entertaining.

semi normal in some parts

spindog · Post by **spindog** » Wed Mar 31, 2010 11:37 pm

kevinb wrote:Their should be an award for the folks that create a 3rd person character and then continue to talk to themselves.

Are you sure that the 3rd person isn't "you" and the rest of the forum? Someone can share information, ideas, and topics without
having a two way exchange. I guess I'm confused by your statement or mabey you don't understand mine.

Rich McVey · Post by **Rich McVey** » Thu Apr 01, 2010 5:34 am

spindog wrote:
kevinb wrote:Their should be an award for the folks that create a 3rd person character and then continue to talk to themselves.
Are you sure that the 3rd person isn't "you" and the rest of the forum? Someone can share information, ideas, and topics without
having a two way exchange. I guess I'm confused by your statement or mabey you don't understand mine.

I understand what Kevin means..

Northwest Fishing Reports

BS Scale and DQ of the month

BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month

RE:BS Scale and DQ of the month